When I was in high school, 1990-1993, there was an incentive program for honor roll students (all A's or A & B) and perfect attendance. One received free food coupons, movie passes, special lunches, etc. for doing well. I realize all student's are not straight "A" students, "A & B" students, and all may not even be able to attend school everyday; but all students should strive to do their best. I have not always been an honor roll student. In elementary school, I received resource help in reading. In junior high, I also struggled to do well, but I studied. I always turned in homework, I would do extra credit work, and above all I pushed to do my best.
I do and do not see a negative side. I realize because some may not be able to accomplish these goals it would appear to be unfair; especially, if one were truly doing their best. Also, something that could hinder a child from applying themselves, is an abusive or unstable home. In all reality, this is not the child's fault, but if the child were to be determined to make it in life they could push for the positive (good grades). Although, I believe most can accomplish these goals. One has to be willing to apply themselves and want to achieve.
The positive side, to this incentive program, is one has an opportunity to decide if the grade is worth the goal. Some are not willing to try unless there is a reward in the end. The good grade should be reward enough, but sadly for some it is not. I hope this program will help children achieve their goals and push those who may not have goals, to decide they want better for themselves.
When I was in middle school we had a program called "Abbot" that was for students who had all A's or A's and B's. I think that most students in school do not like going to school so therefor, they do not try as hard as they can. I agree with the negative aspects that you discussed.
ReplyDeleteI never had any big incentives when I was in school. I just did the best I could and ended up being an honor graduate. You have students who will try hard and get good grades, and you have ones with learning disabilities who try hard and do their best, but maybe cannot meet the standard. They should both be treated equally when you know that they are doing their best. There are also those who just will not try and end up with failing grades. Not everyone is the same.
ReplyDelete